Question AMD Radeon Pro W5700 for mining ethereum

nivrij

Mitglied
Mitglied seit
Nov 6, 2020
Beiträge
35
Bewertungspunkte
7
Punkte
8
I am contemplating about buying this card because someone is offering this to me for a cheaper price here where I live. From my understanding, this card is just the "professional" / "workstation" equivalent of RX 5700 XT.

1609973853980.png

Any thoughts on this card? Has anyone here actually used this for mining? Does anyone know what the hashrate is? Can an unlocked BIOS be flashed on this GPU?
 
Sorry, i dont understand. What do you mean with TRM and A mode?


I use the autofan function in hiveOS, with these settings:
Anhang anzeigen 15130

In the summer months my micron card run with 100% fanspeed most of the time, now mostly between 70% - 80%. I think in winter I can reduce the minimum fanspeed to 20%, then I have maximum 10°C ambient temperature in my garage.

Add this "--eth_config=A" to TRM then TRM will only use Axxx to tune the card before mining.
 
The original W5700 that I messed with, I bricked when I tried flashing a downloaded bios from techpowerup. But was able to flash it back to the original bios by adding a second card which was then installed in the first slot. I then tried a second bios downloaded from techpowerup...this one the AMD 5700XT version and it worked. I did the apple straps and settings as mentioned elsewhere on this site. I have 8 of these cards now, 7 with samsung memory. Samsung cards all get ~56Mh/s @96-100W. Micron card gets 59.5 Mh/s @127W. Only thing is I haven't been able to adjust the memory voltage from the Phoenix miner command line. It just ignores the command. I'm not using Wattman. Settings are per the command line. I did adjust the MPT file as per https://www.igorslab.de/community/threads/gigabyte-5700-xt-bios-mod-fails.3304/post-86493. But it still doesn't drop the memory voltage. Any ideas as to how to be able to drop the voltage? Also when i pull up afterburner it doesn't show up as an option.
 
Hi @Beast819,
using your bios and it's working well with around 56 MH ETH (may be there were any updates? since last upload?)
maybe you had a chance to have a look to w6600 card. if we can get it working like 6600xt but only one 6pin connector it's another good choice to mine.
 
I've been mining with 5 cards using TeamRedMiner in HiveOS
for a while and it had been quite stable. I only had GPU detected dead
or high rejection in one of the card every once in a while.

All I had to do was to shutdown the rig to rest for half an hour
then everything will be stable back for a while.

Recently I just added 8 more cards (total of 13 cards) into the rig
and the rig became completely unstable using exactly the same setting
as when I had only 5 cards.

I've tried almost everything eg;

- Increased power
- Reduced to less aggressive overclock setting
- Changed riser VER006 to VER009 Plus
- Changed to shorter USB cable (1.5m to 1.0m),
- Changed to lolminer
- Reduced to 8 cards (slightly more stable).
- Fixed to PCIe Gen 2.

Update 2
- No matter what settings or miner I used. My rig was completely unstable.
- I removed one of the riser that having some electrical whining noise.
- Removed every components and used hair dryer (non-heat)
to blow all the dust out from my rig.
- Added one more layer of EVA foam underneath all 8 risers.

After I put everything back together then weird problem happened.
My rig wouldn't boot to HiveOS with 8 GPUs installed. Only managed
to boot to HiveOS with only 6 GPUs installed.

If I installed 8 GPUs then it will boot with no display output or sometime
it will show totally corrupted display output.

Then I removed 2 GPUs and left only 6 GPUs installed. There will be display output
if only it entered the HiveOS GUI. No matter what I did, there won't be any output
during boot.

At the end I decided to plug one of the GPU directly on the motherboard
then only it started to give me the display output during post and my rig
because complete stable for half a day now. Total 0 rejection and no GPU detected dead.

I still don't understand why only I plug one of GPU directly on the motherboard
make everything become stable.

Let hope it continue to be complete stable before I make anymore changes into the rig.
 
I think I might just found the culprit that's causing
the instability issue to my rig.

I think it was because VER009S Plus riser bad quality issue.
After replacing all of VER009S Plus back to my old VER006C
then it has been quite stable for almost a day now.

I'm slowly starting to tune back the performance and efficiency
to all of cards now.

I just also noticed that there is white stain all over
the VER009S Plus riser PCB and capacitors for all of my 16 risers.

I'm suspecting that those capacitors are very bad quality and
leaking liquid electrolyte.

I just ordered new 16V 270uF Low ESR solid capacitor to
replace them and see whether I can revive them back to health or not.
 
@Kanuki hi
you should not connect 2 risers with same cable. It's power issue, not enough power for PCI-E probaly

I'm not using 2 risers under the same cable. I'm only using the same cable for 1 riser
then use PCIe 8 pins to Dual PCIe 8 pins cable connect to the card on the same riser.

Maximum supported PCIe 6 pins connector is 75W per connector, PCIe 8 pins connector
is 150W per connector, and less than or equal to 288W per cable.

My previous OC setting was pulling less than 110W (104-108W) for Micron RAM
and around 85-86W for Samsung RAM so it should be much lower than what
a single PCIe power cable capable of.

It was stable for months with 5 cards using VER006C risers (GPU detected dead
happened once or twice a week) until recently I added 8 more cards and also
changed all VER006C risers to VER009S Plus risers.

I dropped back from 13 cards to 8 cards then changed back all the risers back
to VER006C riser and look like it's becoming stable back again.
 
Read my latest messages, there are all the settings, you flash this BIOS and that's it!
I made it based on the unlocked BIOS from MiniMe, with minor improvements from my point of view
May I know what the improvement you made over Mini_Me's ROM?

Are you able to unlock v106 ROM?

I've tried to unlock v106 ROM (Dell) myself
but it bricked my card. I had to short BIOS chip pins
to revive my card.
 
Read my latest messages, there are all the settings, you flash this BIOS and that's it!
I made it based on the unlocked BIOS from MiniMe, with minor improvements from my point of view
Hi, I am not sure if we understand each other.

It is best for me to describe my situation. Recently I got two HP w5700 with 101 bios. I have done my standard procedure flashing the bios with my modified version based on Mini_Me 102 bios. But both cards got bricked. The standard procedure of shorting the bios 1 and 8 pins did not help. I have done this before (shorting pins to unbrick) so this is not my first time. What is new for me is flashing a card, which comes with 101 bios. I have repeated the shorting procedure like 10 times and still nothing. Both cards behave the same. Until I have accidentally shorted the pins 4 and 5 (the opposite diagonal) then bypassing the bios by shorting 1 and 8 works again. Both cards, the same situation. Right now, these two cards have been mining for a few days with original bios 101. Are you saying that you have successfully flashed your card that came with 101 bios with your modified bios? Because there are posts in this thread from people that have been forced to physically remove the bios chip from the card with 101 bios, which became bricked to flash it again in external programmator.
 
Hi.. Guys..

I've set my rig to use auto fan and one of my GPU
is having the abnormal high fan speed.

The fan speed will slowly climb to 84% for a few hours
then TRM will detect this card as dead.

W5700_1.jpg

After that it will continue to work for many hours
then it will repeat the same thing over and over again.

W5700_2.jpg

Judging from the temperature, the abnormal high fan speed may be
causing by the high memory temperature but I didn't clock my vRAM
at very high clock. All of my 8 cards vRAM are running at 890MHz.

I've already replaced my vRAM thermal pads with Thermalright 1.5mm pads
and done the GPU chip thermal paste mod but it did not help much.

Example from Gamer Nexus
W5700_3.jpg

I'm suspecting that either the factory did not bond cooler plate
to the GPU heat sink properly that's why thermal conductivity between
the cooler plate and heat sink is very poor.

or

I'm just unlucky that I received very bad vRAM silicon lottery on this card.
 
Zuletzt bearbeitet :
@Kanuki Can you try this card on a windows machine and check temps via hwinfo64. I think it could be overheating of VRM section or some other part.
 
Ok. I am having trouble finding that ROM. I have searched through the thread. Is it an attachment in this thread or elsewhere?
 
Oben Unten